[corrected] 19 Short Questions about Namespaces (with Answers)

[David Megginson]

[The inevitable typo showed up -- thanks to Adam Donahue and John
Simpson for pointing it out, and even just for reading far enough to
find it.]

	  19 SHORT QUESTIONS ABOUT NAMESPACES (WITH ANSWERS)

				  by

			   David Megginson



		     Monday 8 February 1999 (v.2)



BACKGROUND
----------

For the full specification of XML 1.0, see [1]; for the full
specification of Namespaces in XML, see [2].

This brief review uses James Clark's notation for writing names that
contain both a URI part and a local part.  For example, if the URI
part of a name were "http://www.foo.com/" and the local part were "a",
the name would be written

  {http://www.foo.com/}a

This is purely a convenience notation for the sake of documentation;
it is not defined by any known specification, and is unlikely to be
recognised by any processor.



CHAPTER ONE: The XML 1.0 Perspective
------------------------------------

[Example]

  <a b="x" c="y"/>

[Q] What is the name of the element in the example above?
[A] The name is "a".

[Q] What is the name of the first attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "b".

[Q] What is the name of the second attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "c".

[Q] What do the names mean?
[A] The application determines the meaning of the names.

[Q] How do you write a DTD declaration describing the structure of
    this element?
[A] <!ELEMENT a EMPTY>
    <!ATTLIST a 
      b CDATA #IMPLIED 
      c CDATA #IMPLIED>



CHAPTER TWO. The Namespaces Perspective
---------------------------------------

[Example 2a]

  <z:a z:b="x" c="y" xmlns:z="http://www.foo.com/"/>

[Q] What is the name of the element in the example above?
[A] The name is "z:a" from the XML 1.0 perspective, or
    "{http://www.foo.com/}a" from the Namespaces perspective.

[Q] What is the name of the first attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "z:b" from the XML 1.0 perspective, or
    "{http://www.foo.com/}b" from the Namespaces perspective.

[Q] What is the name of the second attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "c" from both the XML 1.0 and the Namespaces
    perspectives.

[Q] What is the name of the third attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "xmlns:z" from the XML 1.0 perspective; from the
    Namespaces perspective, this attribute is a declaration.

[Q] What do the names mean?
[A] The application determines the meaning of the names.

[Q] What does the namespace URI "http://www.foo.com/" mean?
[A] It has no defined meaning.

[Q] How do you write a DTD declaration describing the structure of
    this element?
[A] DTDs use the XML 1.0 perspective:
    <!ELEMENT z:a EMPTY>
    <!ATTLIST z:a 
      z:b CDATA #IMPLIED 
      c CDATA #IMPLIED
      xmlns:z CDATA #FIXED "http://www.foo.com">



[Example 2b]

  <a b="x" c="y" xmlns="http://www.foo.com/"/>

[Q] What is the name of the element in the example above?
[A] The name is "a" from the XML 1.0 perspective, or
    {http://www.foo.com/}a from the Namespaces perspective.

[Q] What is the name of the first attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "b" from both the XML 1.0 and the Namespaces
    perspectives.

[Q] What is the name of the second attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "c" from both the XML 1.0 and the Namespaces
    perspectives.

[Q] What is the name of the third attribute in the example above?
[A] The name is "xmlns" from the XML 1.0 perspective; from the
    Namespaces perspective, this attribute is a declaration.

[Q] What do the names mean?
[A] The application determines the meaning of the names.

[Q] What does the namespace URI "http://www.foo.com/" mean?
[A] It has no defined meaning.

[Q] How do you write a DTD declaration describing the structure of
    this element?
[A] DTDs use the XML 1.0 perspective:
    <!ELEMENT a EMPTY>
    <!ATTLIST a 
      b CDATA #IMPLIED 
      c CDATA #IMPLIED
      xmlns CDATA #FIXED "http://www.foo.com">


REFERENCES
----------

[1] http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-xml
[2] http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-xml-names



All the best,


David

-- 
David Megginson                 david at megginson.com
           http://www.megginson.com/

xml-dev: A list for W3C XML Developers. To post, mailto:xml-dev at ic.ac.uk
Archived as: http://www.lists.ic.ac.uk/hypermail/xml-dev/ and on CD-ROM/ISBN 981-02-3594-1
To (un)subscribe, mailto:majordomo at ic.ac.uk the following message;
(un)subscribe xml-dev
To subscribe to the digests, mailto:majordomo at ic.ac.uk the following message;
subscribe xml-dev-digest
List coordinator, Henry Rzepa (mailto:rzepa at ic.ac.uk)